Poireau's art Reviews on Newgrounds

[Dreamfall: Zoe Castillo(video)]

The cast shadow is a nice touch, but (on a completely unrelated aspect) the hands seem odd:
- Right hand: looks like it has only 3 fingers (possibly because the thumb rests on the middle finger like it would on the index, ie it's not far back enough + the index is not even hinted at)
- Left hand: is kind of claw-like. The pinky starts a bit far away from the rest maybe, and its metacarp seems too long; the index looks like it's dislocated or something like that (or it's some sort of thumb); the thumb also looks very long before the first knucle, too. Thinking about it, I guess that's a problem of the hand's perspective: the fingers are placed like the hand was resting on the hip, but the palm is actually lifted almost perpendicular to it.

[Ratigan Humanized]

he looks so exactly like it should I can't even remember how the original was :(

[commissions]

The 1st one has me thinking that it is probably more dangerous to wear the armor than not to... But Your art is magnificent anyways, so I don't really care :D

clayscence responds:

haha thank you :D

[La Fille des Marais 2]

10/5, beau dynamisme et chouette compo, en plus d'être joli comme toujours!
par contre elle doit avoir froid aux fesses XD

[Heroes of the Storm]

looks awesome! *.*
as for suggestions... maybe a bit more rythm/movement in the snow could help. I was also thinking about some atmospheric depth but it would possibly sacrifice to much detail on the background characters (especially in small res like we have here)

Ishnuala responds:

I totally agree it lack of depth...I did try to do lesser details on background characters..may be not enough? ok i will try again. Thanks a lot!

[They See Me Strolling]

it also goes along very nicely with your "calling flute" music you just submitted

[My Sanctuary]

holy... wow!
nothing to say but that it's amazing!
(but maybe you should remove the Creative Commons license, which contradicts what is written in your comments)

Utada Hikaru's song is also great, i can see the inspiration.
fantastic work!

clayscence responds:

you are right, I have to change that. thank you so much for your comment :D

[The Gorgeous and the Grotesque]

epic!
sorry I downed your pic's score: misclicked and "voted 2" =( it should have stayed at 5 for ever

DieterTheuns responds:

Aw, it's fine :)
You left a 5 star review, at least that's something :D

[Antique Character Sheet]

I guess he evolved quite a lot since then... 'tis a good thing, the striped t-shirt didn't look well under a vest XD
since comments should include some constructive criticism, let's go for the hat's shadow on the face: it applies as if the face were round; antique's face being flat, the shadow sould be curved downwards and not upwards (or flat, depending on the light's angle). I guess you had figured that out in the 2 odd years since then (I'll check)